Manu Katche: Third Round (ECM 273 2131)
The French drummer’s third album for ECM and another new band. This time he brings in a fellow Sting band member, Jason Rebello, on piano, Pino Palladino on bass guitar and Tore Brunborg on saxophones. There are also briefer appearances by guitarist Jacob Young and singer/trumpeter Kami Lyle.
Brunborg was most recently heard playing both on CD and live with Tord Gustavsen. He is often called a Garbarek-like player but while Garbarek might be the daddy of all these great Scandinavian saxophonists round these days, the younger generation combines Garbarek’s conversational, folk style with a less acerbic tone. Brunborg is one of the most lyrical and lovely to listen to and heard to great effect throughout this disc.
In many ways it is business as usual here, and fans of the first two Manu Katche ECMs will want this one too. However, in early listening I think it may be superficially prettier than those first two but it is also perhaps a little more shallow, especially when we get to the song sung by Lyle.
So, I haven’t yet really felt many great depths here. And one of the previous pleasures that gave those depths was his use of subtle harmonies in saxophone/trumpet lines (first with Garbarek and Tomasz Stanko, then with Trygve Seim and Mathias Eick), whereas this time the saxophone is out front alone, albeit often nicely supported by Rebello.
I am sure it will grow on me, and there is still a lot here to like – all the players are good, the melodies catchy, the dynamics meticulously controlled and the rhythms have that lovely forward motion we have come to expect from Katche – but if you haven’t any Katche in your collection, maybe start with Playground (ECM 173 7321), which remains my favourite.