Christine Tobin & Liam Noble: Tapestry Unravelled (Trail Belle Records, distrib Proper Note TBR01)
In addition to writing some pretty fab stuff herself, the Irish-born, Kent and London resident singer has shown herself to be a wonderful interpreter of other people’s songs. She has leaned increasingly to covering Leonard Cohen rather than Rodgers and Hart, and when her older sister, Deirdre, died last year, Christine recalled how Deirdre had played Carole King’s Tapestry so much when the sisters were young, and how strongly she linked that album to her.
So this project is dedicated to the memory of Deirdre. One doesn’t need to know that to feel the rich resonances in the music.
The singer and her pianist collaborator have changed the order of the songs and Christine has added her original Closing Time to round the album out, but otherwise this is all the songs on King’s Tapestry LP given new interpretations. What is remarkable is how much is achieved in such an apparently unadventurous way. No, that’s not quite the right word, because in a way the most adventurous thing to do is to sing these songs fairly straight and unadorned, and to play them in a relatively unjazzy way, too.
There are few leaps off into improvisation, certainly not from Tobin and only from Noble in the most sensitive and subtle ways. Both musicians have come to that point in their art, it seems, where they have realised the beauty of simplicity and straightforwardness. It’s often the most difficult thing for jazz musicians to do – to avoid the tendency to show off – and yet it is the key to really great music. And I think this is really great music.
Of course you might be wondering – probably especially so if, like me, you also grew up with the original Tapestry album and have it kind of hard-wired into your youth – why you would need another version of it. It’s a thought that completely dissolved for me about 42 seconds into the opening track, Beautiful. Noble’s chunky yet graceful piano intro and the nuanced phrasing of Tobin’s first line were enough to convince me that this disc was going to become even more special to me than King’s.
Songs you have heard a million times and often murdered by poor singers – like You’ve Got A Friend, for example – come up reinvigorated and filled with new depth of feeling. The pair do some lovely spontaneous things at the end of It’s Too Late, while Home Again features a beautiful solo from Noble in the middle of a beautiful bit of singing from Tobin.
It’s not really a CD that I would want to spend a lot of time analysing and trying to describe – that would be to interfere with the magic of it. So suffice to say, if this disc sells as many as Carole King’s original, the world will undoubtedly be a better place. It might have been made as a response to a death, but I can’t remember when I last heard a more direct and profound affirmation of life.
Find out more here

Dino Saluzzi: El Encuentro (ECM 476 3834)