CBSO Centre, Birmingham, England
18-09-10
After a relatively jazz-free summer it was with excitement that I – and, I suspect, many others – headed for the CBSO Centre last night and some fresh, no-holds-barred live music at last. And we were not disappointed.
Birmingham Jazz had set up a strong double bill, a band from either side of the Atlantic who happened to have quite a lot in common. So much so that it became interesting over the two sets to identify the differences rather than the similarities.

Atomic (Picture: Russ Escritt)
Switching the running order from their performance at the Vortex in London, Atomic took the first half. They hit hard but perhaps prematurely with Magnus Broo’s first lip-blistering solo a bit of a shock to an audience that probably needed warming up a little more gently. The sound took a while to settle down. Despite being the only instrument going through the PA, the piano was completely overwhelmed by Paal Nilssen-Love’s (and, heavens, the last thing I would want is to temper this wonderful drummer’s power) but this was perhaps just a problem for those sitting at the front.
When the rest of the band had quietened down and we did get a chance to hear pianist Harvard Wiik, it was on Unity Together with an extraordinary solo: two separate improvisational lines, one in each hand, sometimes contrasting, sometimes complementing, always working in a kind of perfect but skewed logic. It was one of my highlights of the set.
The others were mostly provided by saxophonist Freddy Ljungkvist, who has marvellously developed style which incorporates the blues, free jazz and gutsy lyricism together with a dose of good old showmanship as he almost danced with the enthusiasm of his playing.
Atomic have a great group dynamic, sometimes playing a kind of cool West Coast jazz but then subverting it with complex timing and pauses, and then breaking free with explosive force. Nilssen-Love and double bassist Ingebrigt Haker Fleten are a couple of firebrands so there was no let up in beats or rhythm. Broo used his solo space sparingly but, golly gosh, when he goes for it, he certainly goes for it.
Ljungkvist’s composition Panama had some Latin energy in there with the rest of the band’s heady mix of styles, while the extended set closer, Green Mill Tilter, was a summation of all that had gone before, but lifted to a higher level. Nillsen-Love was steaming by this time and the sax/trumpet lines tight with excitement.

Vandermark 5 (Picture: Russ Escritt)
The Vandermark band, playing all new compositions last night, has a lot in common with Atomic in the way that the free playing grows out of some pretty tightly composed material. Vandermark has stronger “contemporary” compositional leanings, favouring passages of busy percussive abstraction from Fred Lonberg-Holm’s cello and Tim Daisy’s drums on Location, which he will then contrast with a strong riff played by his tenor and Kent Kessler’s bass in unison, before he gives some substantial blowing space to saxophonist Dave Rempis.
The two reedsmen are striking in their different approaches, Rempis favouring a more conventional torrential virtuosity while Vandermark for the most part improvises in a more compositional way, leaving space and varying texture and technique, especially on clarinet.
The make up of the group, with even the cello playing mostly notes rather than chords, gives the band a link to the West African sound of lots of interlacing single lines, and gives the harmonies and chords to the band as a whole.
A fairly gentle ballad with floating harmonies from Vandermark’s clarinet and Rempis’s alto behind long and lyrical lines from Lonberg-Holm had the bandleader joking that ECM might be interested – “Dear Mathias…” – and set us up for the astounding set closer, Leap Revisited. By the time Vandermark and Rempis brought the whole thing to a tumultuous end with some raging double saxophone improv, the ears of all present were well and truly pinned back. The encore was every bit as generous.
While my head valued the bands equally, my heart leaned more to Atomic, mainly due to Ljungvist’s emotional generosity which connected more strongly, and with more warmth.
Both bands play a concentrated, fairly strenuous and uncompromising contemporary jazz, which is never likely to draw a large audience, so it was a bold choice for a season’s opener, but it looks like Birmingham Jazz will be trying to broaden the appeal of its offerings in the months to come. Keep listening and reading…